What's Included in a Roof Replacement

Learn what is included in our roof replacement process

A white house with a large lawn in front of it.

What’s Included in the Cost of a Roof Replacement in Lancaster, PA?

If you’re a homeowner in Lancaster, PA considering a roof replacement, you’re probably wondering:



What exactly am I paying for?


A roof replacement isn’t just about new shingles or metal panels, it’s an entire system designed to protect your home for decades. In this article, we’ll break down everything that should be included in a proper roof replacement in Lancaster, so you can make an informed investment, not just chase the cheapest quote.

1. Full Tear-Off and Disposal

Before a new roof goes on, the old one has to come off — completely. This includes:


  • Tearing off old shingles or metal panels
  • Removing underlayment and flashing
  • Hauling away and disposing of all debris


Lancaster County landfill and disposal fees are typically included in your quote, but be sure to confirm.

2. Roof Decking Inspection and Repair

Once the old materials are stripped away, your roofer should inspect the wooden decking underneath. If any boards are:



  • Rotten
  • Warped
  • Water-damaged


…they need to be replaced before new materials go on.

Watch out for contractors who skip this step or charge extra for every sheet without telling you upfront.

3. Underlayment and Waterproofing

This is your roof’s hidden layer of defense against rain, snow, and ice — especially during Lancaster’s unpredictable seasons.


  • Ice & Water Shield — Applied to roof edges, valleys, and penetrations
  • Synthetic Underlayment — Covers the rest of the decking to shed water
  • Craftsman Roofing Group always uses premium synthetic underlayment, which outperforms traditional felt.

4. Flashing and Roof Penetrations

Your roof isn’t flat — it has vents, chimneys, skylights, and valleys, all of which are prone to leaks if not sealed correctly.

Included flashing work should cover:


  • Chimney flashing
  • Pipe boots and vent collars
  • Step and valley flashing
  • Skylight sealing (if applicable)


Pro tip: Ask if the contractor is reusing old flashing (a red flag) or installing new.

5. Attic Ventilation System

Proper attic ventilation keeps your roof cooler in the summer and prevents ice damming in the winter — both of which extend your roof’s life.



Ventilation may include:


  • Ridge vents
  • Soffit or gable vents
  • Power fans (if needed)


A roof quote in Lancaster should include checking and adjusting attic ventilation. Poor airflow = shortened shingle lifespan.

6. Shingles or Metal Panels + Accessories

This is the visible part of the roof — what most people think they’re paying for. But there’s more to it than just slapping down shingles.



Included in this part of the cost:


  • Architectural or designer shingles OR standing seam metal
  • Starter strips
  • Hip and ridge caps
  • Fasteners, nails, clips


We use full roofing systems — not mix-and-match parts — to ensure your roof lasts as long as your warranty says it will.

7. Manufacturer + Workmanship Warranties

The price of a roof in Lancaster should include two types of warranties:


  • Manufacturer warranty on the materials (usually 25–50 years)
  • Workmanship warranty from your contractor (usually 5–10+ years)


Beware of low quotes with no real warranty behind them. A roof is only as good as the team who installs it.

8. Cleanup, Dump Fees & Final Walkthrough

The job isn’t done until your property is cleaner than it was before. Your quote should include:


  • Dumpster or trailer rental
  • Magnetic nail sweep of yard
  • Final walkthrough with your project manager
  • Photos of work (especially useful for insurance claims)

So, What Should You Expect to Pay in Lancaster?

Here’s a rough cost breakdown for a full roof replacement in Lancaster, PA:

Roof Type Average Cost Range (1,800–2,200 sq. ft.)
Asphalt Shingles $9,000–$17,000
Metal Roofing $15,000–$32,000

Costs vary based on roof complexity, pitch, ventilation needs, and material brand.

Choose a Contractor Who’s Transparent

At Craftsman Roofing Group, we don’t just quote a number. We educate you on every component of your new roof and why it matters — so you can feel confident from day one.



  • No surprise charges
  • Clean job sites
  • Clear warranties
  • Instant online estimates
Close-up of a dark gray shingled roof with a decorative wooden gable against a backdrop of green trees.
A cartoon beaver wearing overalls and a hat is giving a thumbs up.

Ready to See What Your Roof Will Cost?

Get a free instant estimate online in under 60 seconds — no sales pressure, no hidden fees

.

Visit choosecraftsman.com

Proudly serving Lancaster, York, and the surrounding area